Law won't steal rights
THE POST
An upcoming U.S. Supreme Court case will set a precedent regarding a state's ability to determine if grandparents can see their grandchildren against parental objections.
The case, which will be tried in December, will consider a Washington State Supreme Court ruling that declared a law allowing grandparents to file a lawsuit to see grandchildren an infringement on parental rights. If the Supreme Court affirms the law, states could choose whether or not to adopt it.
Opponents claim the law violates a parent's right to raise their child without government entanglement. But justices should overrule the state court because the Washington law does not infringe anyone's rights - it only extends grandparents' rights.
Justices should grant grandparents the opportunity to sue for visitation rights. But grandparent visitation rights should not be guaranteed. State courts still would determine if grandparents should see the grandchildren even if the Supreme Court gives them the right to litigate.
Grandparents biologically contribute to their grandchild's birth, which also gives them the legal right to see their grandchild. Without a grandparent, no parent could exist which, in turn, would mean there also would be no grandchildren born.
Allowing grandparents their day in court will help families settle disputes. The court system arbitrates disagreements and it should decide whether grandparents have the right to see their grandchildren.